معاشرتی سزائیں، اسلام اور مروّجہ پاکستانی قوانین کے تناظر میں
Community based Punishments, in the Context of Islam and the Prevailing Laws of Pakistan
Abstract
Any kind of non-custodial punishment that is carried out with the participation of the community and under the supervision of a government representative is known as community punishment or community sentences. Such punishments are based on the offender's personality, the perpetrator's condition, the offender's background, age, status in society, family, and economic status. Victim consent is also required for these punishments. The Islamic criminal justice system also emphasizes social punishments and similarly, in Pakistan's criminal justice system these punishments have legal status but there is no separate law which deals with social punishments. What are the social punishments in the current laws of Pakistan and what is their status in this research will be examined?
This research has been analyzed and critically reviewed by the author using various libraries and essays on the subject using libraries and the essayist has come to the conclusion that both Islam and Pakistan's criminal justice system have community-based punishments. But the current Pakistani laws are not enough to enforce these punishments and there is a lot of gap in them.
References
Ashworth, A. Sentencing and Criminal Justice 5th ed. )Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, Ashworth 2010), 318.
Abbas Mansoor Abadi, "Bistar-e Mujazaat hai Jamia Mdaar ba Taqeed ber Roeqard Siasat-e Jnai-e Iran", Fasilnama-e Mutahlehat-e Peshgiri az Jurm, (Iran, Shiraz) Issue. 15, (1389 AD), 7.
Ali Hussain, Najfi Abrandabadi, Majmuah maqalaat hmaesh e rahkar hai kahish Jamiat kefir, (Tehran, Mizan, 1386), 115.
Scott, David, "Penology", (London, Sage publications, 2008), 139-140.
Muhammad bin Hassan, Hurr Ameli, Wisai’l al-Shia, Vol. 28 (Qom, Moassisa Aalil Bait, 1409 AH), 150.
A group of writers, Munab-e Fiq-e Shia: trans : Jamia-e Ahdith-e Shia), Vol. 30, (Tehran, Intsharat fFarhangsabz, 1386), 729.
Nasir, Makarim Sherazi, Tafsir-e Namuna, Vol. 08, (Tehran, Darul Kutub Al-Islamiah 1373AD), 190. Syed Muhammad Hussain, Allama Tabatabai, Al-Mizan Fi Tafseer Al Quran, Vol. 09, (Qom, Binyad Ilmi Fiqri Allama Tabatabai, 1378 AD), 422.
Muhammad bin Hassan, Hurr Ameli, Wisai’l al-Shia, Vol. 16 (Tehran, Kitabchi, 1386 AH), 136.
Ibid. 145.
Ibid. 146.
Muhammad bin Hassan, Tusi, Al Khilaf, Vol.5: Tehqeeq wa Tashi Sheikh Ali Khurasani and… (Qom: Dafter Intasharart-e Islami wabasta ba Jamia Huza Ilmaya-e Qom,1407 AH), 497.
Muhammad Baqir bin Muhammad Taqi, 2nd Majlasi, “Hadud wa Qisas wa Diyat: Taqeeq wa tashi Ali Fazil, (Qom, Muassa nasher al Asaar al Islamia, nd.), 59.
Muhammad Taqi, Jaffri, Rassail-e Fihqi, (Tehran, Muassa Manshurat Kramat, 1419AH), 126.
Yahya bin Ahmed bin Saeed, Naziya tul nazar fil jamh biyn al ashyah wal nzaier, Tehqeeq WA tashi Noor udin Wahizi, Vol.1, (Najaf, Matbatul adaab, 1386AD), 119-120.
Shabudin Qrafi, Al-Farooq, Vol. 2, (Beirut: Dar-ul-mahrfa, nd.), 18.
Ahmad Ibn Taymiyyah, Alsiasia Alsharia (Cairo, Alshaab, 1976), 99.
Abdul Salam, Muhammad Sharif, Al-Mubadi Al-Sharia, Vol. 4 (Beirut: Dar Al-Gharb Al-Islami, 1406 AH), 93.
Abdul Aziz Abu Amer, Altehrir fi Alsharia Alislmia (Cairo, Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi, 1996), 393.
Muhammad Abdullah, Wilayat al-Hasaba fi al-Islam (Cairo, Maktab al-Zahra, 1416 AH), 481.
Wahba al-Zuhili, Alfiqa alislami wa Adlata, Vol. 6 (Damascus, Dar al-Fikr, 1409 AH), 206.
2007 Pcr. LJ, 306.
. Muhammad Hussain, Bhutta, Community Based Rehabilitation of Offenders: An Overview of Probation and Parole System in Pakistan, (Pak. J. Criminal, 2(3) 2010), 51-67.
Basharat Hussain, "The History and Development of Probation Service in Pakistan and in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa", Pakistan Journal of Criminology, Volume 5, No. 2, (July-Dec 2013), 30.
Hussain, Basharat, Social Reintegration of Offenders: The Role of the Probation Service in North West frontier Province, Pakistan, (The University of Hull, 2009), 108.
Farooq Ahmed v Federation of Pakistan, PLD 2005, Lahore 15 (6 December 2004).
Amnesty International (2005a), Pakistan: Amnesty International’s comments on the Lahore High Court judgment of December 2004 revoking the Juvenile Justice System Ordinance, AI Index 33/026/2005
PLD 2014 Baluchistan 100
2007 YLR 303.
Anita Abdul Rahim, Tg Noor Azira TgZainudin and others, "Community service as an Alternative Punishment: The extent of its application on the categories of crime and offender in Malaysia", Journal of education and research, Vol. 1, (2013:7).
The probation of offenders ordinance, 1960.
Pakistan Penal code 1860.
Haddud ordinance 1979.
1971 Pcr. LJ 1313.
2007 Pcr. LJ 130.
Juvenile justice system Act 2018 section 9.
Juvenile justice system Act 2018 section 15.
